Luis Enrique’s Legacy: The Throwdown

Listen to the latest Coshcast below! If you enjoy it, subscribe right here on Itunes.

Luis Enrique announced this week that he’s stepping down as Barcelona manager at the end of this season. What kind of legacy does he leave, and who would best replace him? Bernie & Alex discuss:

Is Luis Enrique deserving of the criticism that has come his way?

Bernie: A bit like Claudio Ranieri, this situation is deeper than just performances. It seems the players are not on board with his tactics or his training methods. However, since Pep and Tito the Barcelona players have underperformed under Tata Martino and now Luis Enrique. In Enrique’s case they have largely underperformed yet won the treble and the double. This season Real Madrid are trying to hand the title to the Catalans. Messi might be carrying the team but Enrique is doing something right while his players let him down. I’d say Enrique’s problems are mostly the fault of others. Players failing to perform is tough to fix. The people giving him players like Alcacaer, Jeremy Matthieu and Andre Gomes should be out of a job. He’s done a good job and doesn’t deserve to leave in shame.

Alex: You’re right, definitely a deeper situation here and I tend to have a good deal of sympathy for all Barcelona mangers (unless it one day becomes Ronald Koeman – he is a block of cheese) because politically the club is a nightmare. The board are a shambles, you’re dealing with the influence of Messi and his father, the media are ferocious and a good deal of the fan base seem to freak out at every imperfect result. Meanwhile, the guy has – as you say Bernie – won a treble and a double. And Barcelona may still win La Liga this year. Luis Enrique isn’t perfect – I don’t think he will ever be the man manager that someone like Ancelotti is, but I think he’s earned the right to a dignified exit whatever happens, now.

Is Luis Enrique tactically flexible or anti tiki-taka?

Alex: I doubt he’d describe himself as “pro” or “anti tiki-taka”, but he’s certainly shown that he isn’t overly dogmatic. Luis Enrique has tried to play progressive football wherever he’s coached and people are quick to forget the dazzling stuff Barcelona played during their treble and double wins. You can chalk as much of that as you like up to Messi, Neymar & Suarez but it’s the coach’s job to create an environment in which players like that thrive, and Luis Enrique did that.

Bernie: I don’t believe he’s into tiki-taka. However, I dont think that’s a bad thing at all. He’d have seen how Bayern completely mauled Barcelona on their way to Champions League glory. He probably sees that Barcelona no longer have the players to play that system so he’s tried something different and by all accounts it’s worked. The players don’t seem to like it but they can shove it! Moving away from tiki-taka doesn’t always mean bad football so the critics can pipe down, now. Luis Enrique didn’t strike me as the tiki-taka type of player that Van Gaal moulded the way he did Guardiola so it’s no surprise that he’s not as invested in that philosophy.

Who should take over?

Alex: I wouldn’t want to see him leave the Premier League and he’s an Espanyol man through-and-through, allegedly, but Pochettino would be fascinating, especially if the club is looking for someone to bring youth development back to the fore. Beyond that, Sampaoli is a leading candidate but I wonder whether Barcelona may look internally, again. Definitely not Ronald Koeman. He looks like a baby-bell.

Bernie: Alex, I like Sampaoli but I don’t see him fitting at Barcelona or them going for him. Pochettino could make the move given his penchant for developing youth and lord knows La Masia needs a kick up the backside. However, as you rightly mentioned, his Espanyol connections might work against him. I’m going for Bilbao’s Ernesto Valverde. He seems to fit the post-Guardiola Barcelona bill better. A talented attacking coach who will sit there do as he’s told while the directors of football purchase the players. Pochettino may just want too much control to be considered. As for Koeman…NO!

Well, we certainly agree about one thing, at least.

Look out for another Throwdown next week and in the meantime give us a shout on Twitter and let us know your thoughts on Luis Enrique, and the next move for Barcelona.

3 replies »

  1. Luis Enrique tactically caused Barcelona’s poor form this season. Not to take away from what he’s accomplished but you also have to drown out the noise of management and look at what he’s doing. Rotations are great but shouldn’t happen randomly and haphazardly as Enrique has insisted on doing this season. Injuries or not…Barcelona has not had a steady set of core players playing together for a string of games (with the exception of MSN). His insistence on starting Andre Gomes baffles me. He is the worst of all midfield options available and yet has the most minutes of all midfielders at Barca. He made it difficult to build momentum because the rotations became disruptive. Last season…he had a steady 11 with few rotations to give the starters a rest…that was smart. This season he has chosen to rotate almost every game and that ruins the flow of the team…the passes are slightly off and the understanding isn’t as crisp as it was last season. If you watched Barcelona last season, you’ll notice that they could almost play blindfolded…everyone knew where to be and where each other would be. This season is essentially a get the ball to MSN and hope they make magic. Fortunately they come through due to their quality but it’s not at all sustainable as evidenced by the PSG flogging which was essentially won in the midfield. A tactical annhialation.

    All that said…I, as a Barca fan, am glad he is leaving now as a hero before staying long enough to become a villain. He’s out of ideas (or forcing bad ones) and it’s obvious in the games. Experimentation is good but not at the expense of results. You had the formula Lucho…don’t force an alternative! But Gracias and good luck!

  2. Great comment Kayode. In our answers we’re thinking big picture but you’re right about the the mistakes made this season, and it’s certainly the right time for him to go.

  3. I am embarrassed by my scathing assessment of Enrique as he has now left me in a 2-day state of ecstasy, for which i know not how to subside. His approach and set up of the game was flawless. I knew it from when i saw the lineup and the games leading up to this one. I don’t take back what I said before…I still think those tactics were poor but I regret not having enough faith that he would be able to re-assess and adapt properly. Lucho, if you’re reading this, I apologize!! haha

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s